Imhotep: The Duel Complete Review: An in-depth look at the two-player masterpiece of ancient Egyptian architecture
Experience the architectural rivalry of Nefertiti and Akhenaten in this fun ancient Egyptian experience for two.
In this article, we'll take a deep dive into Imhotep: The Duel by Phil Walker-Harding, which made it onto the Spiel des Jahres recommended list.
We'll show you the appeal of this surprisingly strategic and tense gaming experience, which can be completed in just 30 minutes.
Game Basics
A two-player strategy game named after the great architects of ancient Egypt.
Number of players : 2 players only
Play time : 20-30 minutes
Ages : 10 and up
Designer : Phil Walker-Harding
Release year : 2018
Imhotep: The Duel is a two-player version of the original Imhotep, which was nominated for the Spiel des Jahres in 2016.
It's an excellent combination of worker placement and set collection , centered around a 3x3 grid harbor system .
The game has a sophisticated design worthy of bearing the name of a great ancient Egyptian architect.
The core of the game is a building competition in which players acquire construction tiles from six ships and build four types of monuments .
Each player uses four pieces and can choose one of three basic actions each turn: placing pieces, unloading ships, or performing special actions .
The allure of Imhotep: The Duel
Enjoy deep strategic possibilities born from simple rules and a variety of routes to victory.
A simple yet deep strategy system
A review of Meeple Mountain states, "Limited options make every decision feel important."
With an average game lasting only 15-20 turns, there is no room for wasted moves.
Board Game Quest describes it as "like a good game of chess, players must place their pieces on a 3x3 grid, exploring combinations and opportunities while thwarting their opponent's agenda."
A variety of victory routes with 4 monuments
- Obelisk : Stack tiles vertically, 1 point per tile + 6 points bonus for the player with the most tiles
- Temple : Earn 1 to 4 points depending on the number of red sun symbols
- Pyramid : There are two types, light and dark, and the more of the same color you collect, the higher your score (maximum 21 points).
- Tomb : By placing consecutive tiles numbered 1 to 12 adjacent to each other, you can earn 1 to 25 points depending on the combination.
This variety creates a gaming experience where "multiple scoring routes all feel equally viable" (Gameosity review).
A tense head-to-head battle
Board Game Quest praised the game for achieving "a subtle tone that builds tension with near-direct confrontations."
The review also emphasizes the importance of placement, saying, "It's a 3x3 game. How you line it up is very important."
The ship unloading system is particularly ingenious: "Either player's pieces can unload a ship as long as they have at least two pieces in any row or column" (Meeple Mountain), so you'll always need to read your opponent's strategy and decide whether to take the initiative or undermine their plans.
Action tiles that expand the range of strategies
Blue action tiles are "rule-breaking actions" (Meeple Mountain) that change the game.
- Place 2-3 pieces per turn
- Place one piece and unload one or two ships simultaneously
- Direct acquisition of cargo tokens
- Combination of tile swapping and ship unloading
A review on Gameosity points out the importance of when to use it, saying, "It's very useful, but it takes an entire turn to use."
Concerns and solutions
We will introduce some things to be careful about when playing with experienced players or playing frequently, as well as countermeasures.
With experience, he becomes a destructive player
A German review (fjelfras.de) points out that "experienced players tend to focus more on preventing their opponents from scoring high points than on scoring their own."
Solution : For beginners, we recommend the A-side board, which allows for constructive play.
Japanese reviews also comment that "side A has less of a bargaining element, so it's suitable for playing with people who don't like to get in each other's way."
Lightweight components thanks to tiled construction
Gameosity lamented the change from the original wooden blocks to tiles, saying, "I miss the visual weight of the big chunky cubes."
Solution : A review on fjelfras.de rated the quality as adequate, saying , "It's functional. The individual building materials are delivered in cardboard boxes, as are the location tiles, harbor tableau, and boat tiles."
If you play frequently, the same thing will happen
Board Game Quest points out that "games can start to feel similar if you play them frequently."
Solution : Each monument board has an A and B side, providing different scoring systems, so "there's enough variety to choose from" (Board Game Quest).
Varying the combinations keeps things fresh.
Recommended for these people and occasions
It's a well-balanced game that can be recommended to a wide range of players.
Two-player game enthusiast
Meeple Mountain is "everything I want in a two-player game: streamlined, tactical, and fun!"
"It completely replaces the original Imhotep when it comes to two-player play," he said.
Those looking for a lightweight strategy game
A Japanese player review states , "It takes about 30 minutes and requires just the right amount of brain power. It's perfect for a quick game before going to bed."
It's an exquisite balance, neither too heavy nor too light.
Couples and spouses play
In a comment on Board Game Geek , Kortnee York and her husband are Imhotep fans and expressed their hope for a more aggressive version .
It shows the fun of bringing a new competitive element to their relationship.
Compact gaming environment
A Japanese review said , "The components are all compact, so you can play without taking up too much space," meaning you can enjoy it even in limited spaces.
From strategy game beginners to families
fjelfras.de says , "Very easy to get started. The principles of the game are quickly understood, as are the individual assessments."
The target audience is recommended to be "tactical family players."
Imhotep: The Duel allows you to experience an epic building competition set in ancient Egypt in just 30 minutes. It's a masterpiece that combines deep strategy born from simple rules with the tension that only two players can create.
Why not take on the challenge of carrying on the name of a great architect?
Check the product on the online shopping page
Free shipping throughout Japan. Orders placed before 3pm will be shipped the same day.
Reference source/quote source